Our Companies Suffer from Individualism

COLLECTIVE PERFORMANCE BEYOND INDIVIDUAL PERFORMANCE

Wielding both the stick and the carrot, many companies hang on to a performance management process rooted in individualism and in the rigidity of accounting exercises. What if we valued talent in the service of the shared project?

 

To each his/her own goal

Terms like team, diversity, inclusion are all the rage in the corporate world. In our fast-paced, systemic, ultra-connected society, everyone is singing these benefits to cope with the complexity of our times.

However, individualism has a hard skin. Concerned with performance to generate growth, our companies hang on to a performance management process based on individual performance. With the rhythm of accounting exercises, objectives are cascaded from the top of the organization so that the performance of each person can be judged, rewarded or sanctioned. An ingenious system where the sum of individual performance should mechanically result in collective performance, usually expressed in financial terms.

With objectives and bonuses, we reinforce egos, we create silos, we distort the collective.

By wielding the stick and the carrot, by advocating hierarchy, we continue to promote rigid individual objectives. What does it matter if all employees perform at 90% while the organization fails to meet its ambition? Why do performance management processes remain rooted in individualism and in the rigidity of accounting exercises, on the fringe of the operational reality of companies?

Contributing to the shared challenge

Hasn’t the time come to promote the common good beyond the individual interest?

Agile methods work differently and are inspiring: collective, adaptive and relational replace individualism, planning and resources. With collectively defined ambitions, deadlines adapted to the size of the team, teams that carefully cultivate collective and individual energy. In a team driven by a shared project, the translation of ambition into collective objectives and the collective evaluation of the team’s performance – of and by the team – seem to be common sense. Each person makes the contribution that makes sense to achieve this collective objective. At a frequency adapted to the objective rather than to the accounting year. Individual feedback is then expressed in terms of personal contribution to the collective target.

Collective performance is not the sum of individual contributions but a multiplier.

By starting from the collective, by reversing the mechanics, we promote the shared interest and highlight the talents of each person to achieve it. We promote a culture of learning and improvement rather than judgment and punishment. The collective, the new leader, will spontaneously expel the slackers who don’t fit in.

Of course, all this requires letting go, trust and shared interest. It requires taking care of the collective, developing a spirit of solidarity and mutual aid. When will we understand that the real strength of homo sapiens, the one that has allowed us to develop as humanity, is its formidable collective energy?

References

More inspirations

A storm is blowing at the heart of our companies
Creating business value without depleting resources?

Creating business value without depleting resources?

THE IMPERFECT COMPANY DARES TO BREAK THE MYTH OF ABSOLUTE PERFORMANCE

Sports competitions are a tribute to hyper-performance. Within our companies, sports athletes serve as role models to inspire management teams, applying the techniques and recipes of sports performance to shape corporate athletes: objective, performance, effectiveness, efficiency, optimization are the watchwords.

But at what cost? Our organizations, like those athletes whose hyper-performance is ephemeral, cannot be continually put under stress, remaining at optimum performance without burning out over the long term. Let's dare to explore the idea of the imperfect company, creating value without exhausting its resources.

Read More

A storm is blowing at the heart of our companies
The war for talents, a false good idea

The war for talents, a false good idea

COMPANIES DO NOT OWN THEIR TALENTS

In a society with an inverted demographic pyramid, accelerating technology and where the younger generations (and more) are profoundly changing their relationship to work, the shortage and obsolescence of talent is a major concern for many companies. Poorly armed, the latter have seized on the notion of the talent war at lightning speed to better protect their territory.

How about a change of strategy? As with other types of resources, resource pooling and the sharing economy are proving to be genuine strategies for building a resilient, progressive economy that creates value for all parties.

So why do Human Resources continue to focus on the ownership of talent rather than on accessing and mutualizing it?

Read More

A storm is blowing at the heart of our companies
A culture of autonomy, from HOW to WHY

A culture of autonomy, from HOW to WHY

BEYOND THE RULES, THE SPIRIT OF THE RULES

How many employees have not cursed at times the rules or decisions imposed, for which nobody is responsible and behind which some hide? These decisions, reactions or attitudes turn out to be absurd and unsuited to the situation, leading to disengagement and a sense of disempowerment of the employee.

Gone are the days when employees carry out their activities in accordance with procedures and standards, based on an order or instruction. Faced with the new economic and societal narrative, HR must promote and embody a culture of autonomy, critical thinking and innovation. A culture that encourages local decision-making in the service of the common project.

Starting with HR processes.

Read More

A storm is blowing at the heart of our companies
Dare to trust!

Dare to trust!

TRUST, THE SOIL THAT NURTURES AND STIMULATES SUSTAINABLE COLLECTIVE PERFORMANCE

Almost all leaders are assessed on their financial results. Very few are evaluated on their ability to develop a climate of trust.

As a catalyst for collective energy, trust enables excellence, because it imposes a virtuous circle of improvement to become better. It is by developing this climate of trust that everyone will feel secure enough to be authentic, innovative and enterprising. The leader's responsibility is to cultivate trust as a core value in organizations: trust in oneself, trust in others, trust in the project.

Read More

A storm is blowing at the heart of our companies
Let’s stop recruiting, let’s hire engaged talents!

Let’s stop recruiting, let’s hire engaged talents!

TALENT IN SEARCH OF THE RIGHT ENVIRONMENT TO THRIVE

Talent, that unique thing that one person does better than another, seeks the environment that will allow it to flourish. It is therefore the talent that recruits its company. When recruiting, let's focus on dialogue, authenticity and balance rather than on interviews, screening and power struggles.

Read More

A storm is blowing at the heart of our companies
Silos, these relational gaps

Silos, these relational gaps

TO BREAK THE VERTICALITY OF ORGANIZATIONS, LET'S TAKE CARE OF HUMAN RELATIONSHIPS

In small or large companies, relational silos prevent us from collaborating as we should and relegate the shared project to the background. Sometimes considered as a nuisance to the smooth running of the company, let's value human relationships at the centre of organizations to build innovative companies.

Read More

A storm is blowing at the heart of our companies
This VUCA devil

This VUCA devil

WE CALL OURSELVES AGILE? LET’S LIVE AGILE

Like a devil that bursts out of the box where it had been carefully confined, the term VUCA is on everyone's lips. What strategies should we adopt today facing volatility, uncertainty, complexity and ambiguity? We remain anchored in control to master our environment. Let's cultivate our natural ability to adapt.

Read More

A storm is blowing at the heart of our companies
A STORM IS BLOWING AT THE HEART OF OUR COMPANIES

A STORM IS BLOWING AT THE HEART OF OUR COMPANIES

BETWEEN RESOURCE AND TALENT: IN SEARCH OF A NEW BALANCE

Within companies, there has never been so much talk about meaning and commitment. It is at the top of the agenda of any organization. Paradoxically, we have never seen so many departures, burn-outs, long-term illnesses and questioning of meaning. Talent is shaking up the agenda, much to the disappointment of companies. The COVID crisis has accelerated the projection of companies into the 21st century and opened new fields of possibility.

Read More